A real woman, with real emotions, seems to be more than the novelist can handle. At first, his easy solution is to, "do a rewrite." As he soon finds, life is never that simple.
****** Spoiler Alert. Do not read below unless you've seen the movie ********
On the surface, this quirky film seems to be about a guy who creates and attempts to control a girl through some magic from an alternate reality. Not so. Notice that Calvin is using an old-fashion typewriter throughout his antics with Ruby. It is not until he begins to write the book The Girlfriend, that he is suddenly using a laptop as most writer's would. His choice of writing instrument is important because it gives us a clue to the truth. From the very beginning of the film, to point just before Calvin is reading his new novel at the book signing, we have been "watching" his book The Girlfriend. The seemingly impossible magic that the viewer witnesses, is actually the creative writing of the author, Calvin,
The overall theme remains. Calvin has a lot of issues dealing with people in general and woman he'd like to be close to specifically. The writing of the book acts as a kind of a catharsis which assists him in understanding more about himself. Whether this "book therapy" helps him to more effectively relate to the new person he meets at the end of the film remains to be seem.
************** End of Spoiler Alert ****************
As impressed as I was with this film, I was delighted to find out that Zoe Kazan herself wrote the screenplay. Another fact is that the two lead characters have been dating each other since 2007.
Some credit must also be given to Anette Bening, Antonio Banderes, Eliott Gould and Chris Messina for adding texture to this film but well deserved applause goes to Ms. Kazan and Mr. Dano who superbly makes us believe that wherever the heart goes, there will always be magic. I can easily give this movie five out of five stars.